“What a cute baby. How old is he?”
“4 days. We can’t wake him up.”
Some days, from nowhere this conversation echoes in my mind – I can see the ER counter in front of me and know exactly what position I was holding Pumpkin in when the nurse who commented on how very sweet looking he was plucked him from my arms. No one at the ER cared about our names or if we had health insurance – they barely cared if Spouse and I could keep up with them. We watched the very definition is “springing into action.”
Pumpkin had been born on a Friday and this was the following Tuesday. He had been a normal active baby at his 10am check up that morning and by 5pm he had slipped into a coma-like state: unwilling to eat; limp as a ragdoll; unresponsive to pinches and other pain; and finally no eye movement. At our check-up our doctor noted that he had lost too much weight and that Pumpkin needed to eat every 2 hours, no exception and we were to return the next day. All he needed to do was gain an ounce.
But we didn’t make it that far. We left the pediatrician at 11am and fed Pumpkin. He didn’t want to eat at 1pm but he ate around 2pm. At 4pm we tried to feed again and had trouble waking him. He roused a little but no eating. Within the hour we watched as he fell into a deep sleep and went limp – unresponsive to any noise, touch, light, anything.
The ER staff at St. Rose Siena was fantastic – covering all bases with us, testing and monitoring. They have a pediatric ER so our doctors were there for children only and knew their stuff. They assured us it was most likely dehydration but tested for everything else one can test for with blood samples and a spinal tap. Though still largely unresponsive, Pumpkin did cry some for the spinal tap. Heart-wrenching to know he was in pain; relieving to know he was still able to respond. Though I thought the obvious thing was to tell us if he was going to survive no one mentioned that for a few hours. That’s because all his vitals were fine so the medical staff didn’t see this as a risk, didn’t occur to them. Regardless, it was all I could think of and once my baby left my arms, I started crying. Not weeping or wailing just tears streaming down my face. Not knowing, feeling failed, scared and helpless was intense and awful. That feeling and the tears pretty much continued for 30 hours – when, after bags and bags of IV and routine every two hour feedings, Pumpkin let out a vicious cry all on his own. It was, without doubt, the most beautiful sound I had ever heard.
In that time, Pumpkin’s test came back clean – no meningitis, no brain infection. He had an EEG which determined that his brain had shut down everything but what was essential to stay alive. Smart baby. They had not ruled out metabolic disorders yet (though a few weeks later those were ruled out via test results). The nursing staff focused on feeding him – we were still trying for every 2 hours. I was breastfeeding and the hospital staff supported me 100%. I had a Medela industrial pump in our room and I pumped every 2 hours while we fed Pumpkin Similac. That revealed something important – I wasn’t producing but drops of milk. After the colostrum, though I thought it had, my milk never came in. Pumpkin hadn’t really been getting any food despite sucking for appropriate amounts of time and there being milky residue on my breast. I was producing a small bit – but only about 1/6 of what was needed. We were measuring in milliliters, like less than 10 ml per pumping (newborns go for 30-90 ml per feeding).
After a little over 24 hours of feeding the formula, Pumpkin started to come around. The EEG was done by a pediatric neurologist on Wednesday and when he made his rounds on Thursday he thought he had the wrong baby – Pumpkin had revived! The doctor called him a whole new baby. And he was! Crying, squirming, pooping…he was doing all the wonderful things that newborn babies do.
Once Pumpkin wailed of his own volition, we felt we were past the darkest period of this trauma, and our doctor diagnosed dehydration as the most likely culprit, my thoughts turned to “Why? How did we not see this coming? Why doesn’t every piece of literature mention dehydration?”
I thought I had missed something – this had to be our fault. For those of you who know me, you know I am a researcher. I like to research, to know, to plan. So I reviewed everything I had read (The Baby Book, What to Expect When You Are Expecting, Your Pregnancy Week by Week, What to Expect the First Year, The Nursing Mother’s Companion) – and I had a hard time finding anything in any of those books that address dehydration in the first days. Yet the hospitalist told us that the see this in 4-5 day old infants fairly routinely. Where is the information on newborn dehydration?
Even targeted internet searches reveal little information (and, of course, having to search is the problem – the info isn’t in the obvious, commonly accessed places) . There are lists of symptoms. Key symptoms are: lethargy; fussiness; sunken fontanels; more than 6 hours without a wet diaper; lack of bowel movements; cold, splotchy looking hands and feet; improper sucking and excess weight loss (>10% birth weight). There are instructions on what to do: call your doctor or go to the ER. The best resource I found at the time is a Le Leche League article that is defending breastfeeding as a “cause” of dehydration in the face of a TV new program that identified dehydration as a danger of breastfeeding. But this isn’t part of their basic web-based literature (I did not read The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding, the main LLL publication, so there could be an extensive discussion there). In a web search today I found an article from the European Journal of Pediatrics from July 2009 that shows 1 of 66 breastfed babies suffer dehydration (about 1.5%). Hardly an epidemic, I understand that. Still, overall, I found the parent-prep books and resources to be lacking on this topic.
As such I want to tell everyone our story – to make sure new parents know what to look for and what precautions to take. Pumpkin went into this hibernation so quickly – about 6 hours – and we, luckily, took all the right steps but it would have been so easy not to. I am certain that we would have avoided this all together if we had just known a few things – and how I wish all those books would dedicate the one page necessary help those of us in that small 1.5%!
Here is what I learned and what I want every new parent to know:
- Key indicators to look for. The basics are weight gain/loss, wet diapers, and consistent milk intake. These are all good individual indicators but really they all work together. We relied heavily on one indicator – the diapers – and that was a mistake.
- Breastfeeding is a wonderful, natural, nutritionally perfect system to feed babies. But not every mom will produce milk and not every mom will know when or what support to get. See a lactation consultant and be vigilant – but also know that it is ok to supplement. A little formula is way better than a little coma. I saw 7 lactation counselors and took a lot of supplements before we resigned ourselves to full-time formula feeding. Many breastfeeding proponents will say that it is very, very rare for milk to not come in and while I can’t attest to the percentages, when I told my story to friends and family it was a fairly common occurrence. Some women had even had their prolactin levels tested to find them off the bottom of the charts. There is a real possibility that a mother won’t produce milk – pumping is a good way to see how much is being produced and alleviate any concerns.
- Pumpkin-head had been producing wet diapers reliably. But as it turns out because he had been delivered via C-Section there was a lot of fluid being flushed from his body (rather than having been squeezed out in the birth canal). What we thought was a reliable indicator was not – and no one had clued us in (not nurses, doctors, books, lactation consultants, web-sites) that extra fluid is very common with C-Section and so diapers could not be as relied upon as an indicator as they could with a vaginally delivered baby. The journal article referenced above indicates that C-Section babies have a 3.4 times higher risk of dehydration.
- Pumpkin’s loss of weight revealed at the pediatrician’s office was a big indicator but because we had been having trouble waking Pumpkin-head for feeding from the start our doctor thought the increase in feeding for a day would correct the trend. Perhaps because of all the drugs in my and Pumpkin’s system at the birth, he was very sleepy, very hard to wake. Though for months after this event he remained hard to wake for feeding – we did it nonetheless. In those first days we thought maybe he needed sleep and his system would know when he needed food. Not true – the first of undoubtedly many times parents will have to guide kids to what is right and needed. Another problem with this indicator is that very few people have a baby scale at home. Those scales measure to the ounce and most adult scales are simply not that reliable. An early check-up at the pediatrician will help remedy this (like a day or two after you arrive home). Plus your doctor’s office should be happy to let you visit and weigh your baby in the days following his birth. This really is the most fail safe indicator to track. Here in Vegas we have the WomensCare Centers that all have breastfeeding support including free access scales – if we have a second child, you can bet I will be there for a weigh in each day until a pattern of weight gain is established.
As a new parent I was aware that dehydration was a possibility during illness or in the heat, but I didn’t understand the basic risk of dehydration in the early days of life. And because I am a researcher, a planner, a woman who uses resources, I feel like if I missed this important topic in the literature others could easily be unaware as well. So that is why I am posting this – I wouldn’t wish those 3 incredibly difficult days on anyone – parents, babies or the people who love them.
Below is a picture taken after Pumpkin revived – maybe midday on the Thursday. It is one of the most cherished pictures I have of him. In some ways it was like he was born right then – he had, at the very least, come back to life. The sun on his precious face…it was a new beginning, a year ago today. Maybe we are the only silly parents who were unaware of this real risk and how all the indicators work together, but in case not, please share this with anyone you know expecting a new baby.


Hi there,
This is a great post– my baby, now 12 days old, went through something similar. it is absolutely true that we (new parents) are not taught about the risks of breastfeeding (dehydration+ starvation). All babies are not born equally– some with lower starting birth weights, or less coordinated ability to suck; some will be much more prone to the deleterious effects of breastfeeding. In that case, by giving them formula you are SAVING THEM not hurting them, as many hospital staff (nurses/lactation consultants) might make you feel.
I wish more people knew about this ahead of time.
I imagine this experience will stay with me forever as well. It took a lot of work to let go of not being able to breast feed either of my boys but keeping them healthy is what I focus on. How wonderful that your daughter had two little girls and was able to provide breast milk for them – as well as lots of love, I know. Thank you so much for visiting and sharing!
Wow! I am glad you followed your instincts! (and disregarded that doctor…) I agree there needs to be more focused education in the hospital materials and the breast feeding literature on this. Thanks for reading and sharing your experience.
Wow!!! I am a 61 year old grandmother and I remember my first-born’s experience like it was yesterday. I, too, have never heard of infant dehydration, but finally after all these years I believe that was what occurred to my first baby. I had such good intentions to breast-feed and tried over and over in the first hours at the hospital after giving birth. The nurses and my dr. yelled at me and scolded me for not forcing her to eat. I tried everything I was told to do to get her to eat, and then we went home and I worked and worked with her. After 2 weeks I took her in for a check-up and without any explanation to me, my dr. abruptly told me to quit nursing and put her on formula. I was very angry-for the treatment I got from the dr. and for not being told why. She had lost an ounce or 2 at the check-up and yet no one explained anything to me. I really felt helpless. I have beat myself up over this for years because I feel I failed my children. I think I can finally put this issue to rest. Thankfuully, this same daughter is a wonderful mom herself who was able to successfuully breastfeed 2 girls for almost a year each.
Thank you so much for writing this. We had almost the same experience with our 4 day old. In hindsight, I feel the hospital failed us by releasing us when his weight was down almost 10% and his diaper counts were very low. I feel I was under educated and only because I had a knowledheable friend and a gut feeling did we bring him in to the ER. And when we called our insurance provider to get the OK to go to the ER, the doctor on call said he didn’t feel we should come in, despite my list of all the signs of dehydration! But we went in anyway, and 2 days later after all the tests, IV fluids, and formula fedings, our baby is thriving. And I feel a little less guilty and responsible.
[...] heart-wrenching experience a few days after Pumpkin’s birth when he was back in the hospital for severe dehydration. Since that time we have been going for checkups with a pediatric neurologist. At a time when [...]
Our experience was similar to yours, though my kids were later diagnosed with a genetic disease after rounds of metabolic/genetic testing. Breast feeding in the early stages should be closely monitored to be sure the baby is getting enough milk and mothers should know this is a possibility or risk and know how quickly things go downhill and what to look for – thank you for sharing your story!
Thank you for sharing this story. It made me remember when I came home with our oldest son. I pumped and let him letch on faithfully every 2 hours. Our doctor told us basically right away that he was not getting enough food. So we got a nipple shield and let him suck with a little tube stuck in the side of his mouth where he actually sucked formula out. After a few weeks he was so frustrated that he just wanted to eat from a bottle. I kept on pumping and invested in a $300+ breast pump, and a rental one, nothing brought my milk in. A month later I still produced only 50 ml every 2 hours. But by then I was so depressed and exhausted that I gave up.
Then baby #2 came along and I was able to pump 70 ml, out of both breasts after 6 weeks. Here again I gave up.
7 month ago we finally had our daughter. She ended up in the NICU.
I saw 6 different lactation councelors, my insurance paid for a new breast pump, which was suppost to be one of the leading pumps, but it was not even half as good as my older breast pump I had worked with before. I used mostly the hospital pump while she was in the NICU. After 2 weeks in the NICU she finally came home with us, and again, by then I produced a whole 47 ml.
The “check up” phone calls from the lactation councelors were the hardest on me, when I had to tell them that I am still trying but not much is coming out. Even they acted like:”You are doing something wrong or you are lying about pumping every 2 hours!” But I wasn’t lying, and the worst was, I still blamed myself!
It came much later that I found out that actually a lot of women have the same problem I have, I don’t produce milk!
In a way I am jealous of the women who don’t have that problem, but I am now more mad at all those people who make women like myself feel like worthless freaks. It is not our fault that we don’t produce milk, but still, People who should help us, or at least somehow support us, like doctors, nurses, lactation councelors, and often even friends, blame us for “not trying often enough”, or “doing something wrong”.
I hope this story, and maybe even my story, will help a few young mothers out there to understand that it is “not your fault” if you don’t produce milk, and it is ok to feed your baby formula.
Wow as a mother of 5 kids I never heard of that. I had 2 by c-section and I did not no they retained water from that either. But what I did notice with my last child my breast got no milk I was glad since I never breast feed but I did ask why and I got no answers from the nurses at the hospital or the nurs that came and visit a few days after my last was born. So ya I really think there is alot of thing even though the percentage rate is low that all parents should be aware of. I think it is great you took the time to post this message and congratulations. i am glade to hear he is doing fine now.
What a frightening experience…thank you for sharing it. I am also a mom who read all the books and researched motherhood as much as possible when I was expecting and don’t remember reading about dehydration. I will certainly pass this information along to new moms I know…again, thank you!
Our experience with Porter’s jaundice was similar–he wasn’t sucking properly due to his prematurity, so he wasn’t eating enough from my breast or bottle, so he wasn’t pooping enough and pushing out bilirubin. God, all of the feelings Aaron and I went through seeing our new baby BACK in the hospital–I don’t wish that on anyone.
I am so glad that Pumpkin is okay now. Thank you for educating new parents out there.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Jennifer O., Katie . Katie said: Bean was hospitalized at 5 months old for dehydration. I wish I'd read this blog post before he got so sick… http://bit.ly/cupWJz [...]
This is such a great post and so thorough. My son didn’t have his first doctor visit until he was 4 days old and when the doc saw him, he said he was dehydrated too. The doctor was VERY upset. I freaked out and thought I was the worst mom in the entire world. No one told me I should worry about him getting enough breastmilk. I thought it wouldn’t be a problem.
My son had been so fussy once we brought him home from the hospital and we couldn’t figure out why. My motherly instinct told me to give him formula, but I didn’t want to give in.
Like you said…there is not enough information out there in pregnancy books to warn new parents. Thanks for this post! I will share it!
Excellent post, Tan. Bean was hospitalized for dehydration (and other things) when he was about five or six months old. It was the worst four days of my life in the hospital with him. And you are right, after you go through something like that, you look back and think, “It’s such a simple thing to recognize if that’s what you’re looking for, so why didn’t anyone tell me to look for it?!?!?” I hope this post will help even just one more mom look for the right symptoms so they don’t have to go through what we went through.
~ Katie
http://www.marriageconfessions.com